Philip G. Thompson, Esq.
Florida Supreme Court Certified Circuit Civil Mediator
Florida Supreme Court Qualified Arbitrator
Introduction
In many mediations, the parties mutually agree that opening statements would add little value or could hinder productive negotiations. In those situations, the mediator should proceed directly to caucus. More challenging circumstances arise when the parties disagree: one party wishes to make an opening statement, while another wants to forego openings.
When this occurs, who decides? Does the mediator have the authority to dispense with opening statements over a party's objection, and if so, what factors should guide that decision? This article examines the mediator's discretion under Florida law and the prevailing ethical standards, as well as the competing considerations that should inform the exercise of that discretion.
The Mediator Is in Control
Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.720(h) states: the mediator shall (emphasis supplied) be in control of the mediation and the procedures (emphasis supplied) to be followed in the mediation . Accordingly, the mediator has broad authority to determine how the mediation will be conducted, including whether opening statements will be permitted. But how does the mediator go about making this decision? What if anything should the mediator consider? Is the mediator permitted to make this decision in an arbitrary or capricious manner?
The Mediator's Responsibility to the Parties
At present, there is no authority that grants a party the unfettered right to make an opening statement at mediation. Nor is there any authoritative source that expressly dictates what factors, if any, must be considered by the mediator when making this call. However, there are sources that provide some clues on how to navigate this issue. Those clues lie in various pronouncements made generally about a mediator s ethical responsibilities to the parties. Here, the key responsibilities are safeguarding the mediation process and ensuring that the parties can execute self-determination in a fair and even-handed manner.
Self-Determination and the Needs of the Parties
In 1991 the Florida Supreme Court created a committee to draft and present for adoption, a set of ethical standards for Florida mediators. In 1992, the Standards of Professional Conduct for Mediators was created. Part II of those Standards is the Rules for Certified and Court Appointed Mediators (hereafter the Standards ). Rule 10.400 of the Standards states generally that a mediator is responsible for safeguarding the mediation process. Rule 10.230 of the Standards lists six concepts that mediation emphasizes. Two of them are self-determination and the needs and interests of the parties. Rule 10.300 of the Standards states further that a mediator has a responsibility to honor the parties right to self-determination. Additionally, the committee notes to Fla.R.Civ.P. 1.720 state that the concept of self-determination in mediation contemplates the parties free choice in structuring and organizing their mediation sessions.
When these authorities are read in pari materia, they suggest that a mediator should not dispense with opening statements arbitrarily or simply because one party objects to them. Although Rule 1.720 grants the mediator control over mediation procedures, that discretion is informed by ethical obligations, including the duty to respect party self-determination. A party's right of self-determination extends to how that party chooses to present its position and participate in the mediation process.
The issue becomes more complex when the parties have conflicting views regarding the structure of the mediation. If one party believes an opening statement is essential to advancing its interests while another believes openings would be counterproductive, the mediator's decision will inevitably affect one party's preferred method of participation. In such circumstances, the mediator should carefully balance the competing interests of the parties and determine which approach best serves the fairness and integrity of the mediation process.
Depending on the circumstances, that analysis may support allowing opening statements or proceeding directly to caucus. For example, in a family-law mediation involving allegations of domestic violence, requiring the alleged victim to sit through opening statements may cause significant emotional or psychological harm. In that situation, the need to protect the alleged victim and preserve a safe mediation environment may outweigh the opposing party's interest in presenting an opening statement. Accordingly, dispensing with openings may be necessary to safeguard the participants and/or the mediation process itself.
Advisory Opinions
Additional guidance on this issue can be found in advisory opinions issued by the Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee (MEAC). In MEAC Opinion 2011-012, a mediator asked whether parties could be prohibited from using cell phones during mediation to prevent them from discussing the proceedings with non-participants. MEAC concluded that mediators do not have the authority to impose such a blanket prohibition. Although the opinion did not involve opening statements, MEAC emphasized an important principle: a mediator may not make unilateral decisions or adopt policies that unduly interfere with a party's right to self-determination.
That principle is instructive in the context of opening statements. A mediator should not adopt a standard policy requiring the parties to proceed directly to caucus, nor should opening statements be skipped solely for the mediator's convenience. If one or more parties wish to present an opening statement, summarily denying that opportunity may impair a party s ability to structure and participate in the mediation process in the manner they believe best serves their interests.
For many parties, the opening session represents the only opportunity before trial to speak directly to the opposing party and counsel. An effective opening statement can really move the needle and sway the opposing party. As such, there are parties that insist on making an opening statement for this reason. Such a decision is one facet of that party s right of self-determination to structure and organize their mediation session. Accordingly, a mediator should not dispense with openings for personal convenience or without a reasoned evaluation of the parties' competing interests. When the parties disagree, the mediator's role is not to arbitrarily favor one position over another, but to assess and weigh the competing interests of the parties to determine which approach will best preserve a fair, balanced, and effective mediation process.
Another instructive opinion is MEAC Opinion 2016-001, which addressed whether a mediator may dispense with the joint opening session and proceed directly to caucus. The issue did not arise from a disagreement between the parties regarding opening statements. Rather, it involved small-claims mediations concerning credit card debt collections. The inquiring mediator observed that creditor attorneys were using the opening session to question pro se debtors about matters unrelated to settlement, apparently for the purpose of gathering information that could be used in subsequent collection efforts if the case did not settle. Concerned that the mediation process was being used as a discovery tool rather than for dispute resolution, the mediator asked whether bypassing the joint session and proceeding directly to caucus would be appropriate.
In response, MEAC emphasized that a mediator's primary obligation is to safeguard the mediation process. The Committee explained that when the interests of fairness and balance are best served using caucus as a procedural tool, a mediator is not prohibited from employing it. MEAC further noted that mediation should be conducted in a manner that preserves the integrity of the process and protects participants from unfair procedural advantages.
Opinion 2016-001 illustrates that, although mediators have broad discretion to control the structure of a mediation, that discretion must be exercised in furtherance of their ethical responsibilities. Procedural decisions should not be based on convenience or preference, but on whether they promote a fair, balanced, and collaborative mediation. Accordingly, when the parties disagree about whether opening statements should occur, the mediator should evaluate the competing interests at stake and determine which approach will best safeguard the mediation process while remaining faithful to the principles of fairness and party self-determination.
The Big Take Away
Absent a compelling reason to do otherwise, a mediator should permit opening statements when one or more parties wish to make them. While a mediator has broad authority to control the mediation process, that authority must be exercised in a manner that respects party self-determination and promotes a fair and balanced proceeding. For many participants, the opportunity to address the opposing party and counsel during a joint session is an important component of the mediation process and a meaningful expression of how they choose to present their case.
That does not mean opening statements should occur in every mediation. There are circumstances in which they may undermine productive negotiations, create an imbalance in the process, or cause harm to a participant. When those concerns are present, a mediator may appropriately conclude that proceeding directly to caucus better serves the interests of fairness and the integrity of the mediation process.
Ultimately, the decision whether to conduct opening statements should be made on a case-by-case basis. The governing consideration is not whether opening statements are generally beneficial or detrimental, but whether allowing or dispensing with them will best promote a fair, balanced, and effective mediation under the unique circumstances presented. In some cases, that analysis will favor opening statements; in others, it will support proceeding directly to caucus. The mediator's task is to exercise informed discretion consistent with the interests and needs of the parties as well as the mediator's ethical responsibilities. The mediator should carefully evaluate the specific circumstances of the case, weigh the competing interests involved, and determine which course of action best safeguards the mediation process.
